In our demanding field, effective professional supervision isn’t merely a checkbox exercise; it’s the lifeline for sustainable practice. It’s a dedicated space where we can pause, process, and truly grow. The Reflective Learning Model, to me, offers the most profound way to achieve this. It moves us beyond just ‘doing’ to deeply ‘understanding.’ While we’ve discussed its core ideas before, today, I want to walk you through exactly how to put this powerful Reflective Learning Model into practice during your supervision sessions. This model helps transform raw experience into invaluable learning.
Setting the Scene: Intentional Beginnings and Agenda
Every supervision session, especially with the Reflective Learning Model, starts and ends with purpose. It’s about more than just pleasantries. This mindful approach creates a safe, trusting space. We need to be fully present for each other. Sometimes, it’s a simple shared cuppa. Other times, it’s a quiet moment, honouring our cultural roots, perhaps a brief karakia. This deepens our connection.
Setting your agenda and goal
Once settled, we shape our agenda. This is primarily your time, you’re learning journey. But I’ve seen it often: what we think we need isn’t always what we truly discover. So, while your priorities lead, I might gently introduce other vital areas. This ensures our time together is purposeful, comprehensive, and truly focused on your development.
| What is my agenda? | What do I want to achieve? | Has my goal achieved? |
Taking about 30 minutes beforehand really helps. Ask yourself, “What’s my agenda?” This simple question makes a huge difference. Aim for 2-3 items on your agenda. If something’s complex, one is perfectly fine.
Once you have your topics, think: “What do I want to achieve?” For example, say you want to discuss that stressful domestic violence case from last week. Why bring it up? Maybe you want to explore your emotions. Or perhaps you’re looking for ways to manage your feelings better next time. You might even want feedback on your intervention.
Clearly defining your goals helps your supervisor understand exactly what you need. They can then ask the right questions and truly help you. Your supervision is a valuable growth opportunity. Make the most of it!
Examples
In a different session, Aroha arrives just as agitated. She begins sharing the immediate emotional impact. After a few minutes, when she’s had space to articulate her initial feelings, I gently interject. “Aroha, that sounds incredibly tough. Is this specific interaction where you want us to focus our supervision time today? Or are there other, equally pressing matters for our agenda?”
Aroha pauses. My question creates a valuable pause. She takes a breath. It allows her to shift perspective. She debriefs the immediate emotion, but then clearly prioritises a complex family dynamics issue. One that truly needs our collaborative problem-solving. She leaves feeling satisfied, knowing both her immediate needs and her deeper learning goals were met. This is the power of a shared, purposeful agenda.
The Reflective Learning Cycle in Action
At the heart of the Reflective Learning Model is its four-stage cycle: Event, Exploration, Experimentation, and Evaluation. This isn’t a strict linear path. We often move back and forth, revisiting stages as new insights emerge. Each agenda item benefits from this iterative process. It’s designed to transform raw experience into profound, lasting learning.
Stage 1: The Event – Naming the Experience
This first stage is about clearly naming the ‘event.’ What specific experience, challenge, or dilemma are you bringing today? It could be anything: a complex client interaction, a difficult team dynamic, or your own reaction to a tough professional situation.
My role here is to help you articulate why this event matters. What do you hope to resolve? How do you want to work on it with me today? Sometimes, just clearly putting words to the ‘event’ brings an initial sense of clarity. It’s like shining a spotlight on what needs attention.
For example, a social worker might start by saying:
- “I’m really struggling with a young person in my caseload. They’re just not engaging, and I feel like I’m hitting a brick wall. I need help figuring out why.”
- “I had a really intense meeting with my manager last week. I left feeling completely unheard. I want to understand what happened and how to handle it next time.”
- “I’ve noticed I’m feeling incredibly drained after certain client visits lately. I’m wondering if this is just stress, or if it’s something more. Maybe even burnout.”
This initial naming helps us pinpoint the ‘concrete experience.’ It’s the essential starting point for our journey of reflection. We recognise the ‘what’ and its significance.
Stage 2: Exploration – Unpacking the Layers
Once the event is clear, we move into ‘exploration.’ This is where we truly unpack the situation. We look at it from all angles. I’ll encourage you to describe more than just the facts. What were your thoughts during the event? What feelings were present, both for you and for others involved? What assumptions might you have been holding? This is where true ‘reflection’ begins. We uncover how the experience impacted you, and critically, how you impacted the experience.
Our conversation might include prompts like:
- “Tell me more about your internal experience during that interaction. What specific emotions surfaced when the young person disengaged?”
- “What thoughts immediately ran through your mind when your manager made that comment? Were you making any assumptions about their intentions at that moment?”
- “Describe how that feeling of being drained manifested during those client visits. What physical or emotional cues did you notice within yourself as you left?”
This stage requires an open, non-judgemental space. It’s about bringing subconscious insights to light. Sometimes, we find that deeply held assumptions, once examined, can open entirely new ways of understanding. It takes courage to be vulnerable here, but it’s where real growth happens.
Stage 3: Experimentation – Envisioning New Approaches
Having thoroughly explored the event, we transition to ‘experimentation.’ Now, we consider new possibilities. What could you do differently next time? What new strategies or interventions might you test? We engage in a ‘conceptual analysis,’ linking your experience to relevant theories, research, or ethical guidelines. This phase helps us formulate a new action plan. My role isn’t to give you the answers. Instead, we collaboratively discover solutions. Solutions that feel right for you, that you can truly own and implement.
Our discussion might lead to questions like:
- “Given what we’ve uncovered, what new approaches could you try with this young person to foster better engagement? Let’s brainstorm some culturally sensitive, creative strategies together.”
- “If you were to re-enter that conversation with your manager, what might you say or do differently? How could you articulate your perspective to lead to a more constructive outcome?”
- “Based on your insights, what practical changes could you implement in your daily routine or self-care practices to address that fatigue? What support might you need from your team or organisation?”
This stage is about “active experimentation.” It’s taking the learning from our reflection and turning it into tangible steps. It’s about bridging the gap between insight and action.
Stage 4: Evaluation – Learning from Outcomes and Adapting
Finally, we reach ‘evaluation.’ This crucial stage involves reflecting on the outcomes of your ‘experimentation.’ What happened when you tried that new approach? What did you learn from that experience? What worked well, and what perhaps didn’t go as planned? This brings us back to a new ‘concrete experience,’ ready to re-enter the cycle. This continuous loop makes professional supervision a dynamic, ongoing process. A constant journey of learning and growth.
We might prompt this discussion with questions such as:
- “After trying that new engagement strategy with the young person, what were the results? What did you observe in their response? What did you learn about your own refined approach?”
- “How did that follow-up conversation with your manager unfold? What was the impact of your adjusted communication style? Were there any unexpected outcomes or surprises?”
- “Since incorporating those self-care strategies, how has your energy level and overall well-being been impacted? What positive shifts or ongoing challenges have you noticed in your practice?”
This iterative cycle allows us to continuously refine our professional practice. It’s where theoretical understanding truly meets real-world application. It enhances our competence, adaptability, and resilience as social workers in New Zealand. A truly rewarding process.
A Practical Example: The Reflective Learning Model in Action
Let’s walk through a concrete example. One that shows how this model can play out in a typical supervision session. While this scenario might feel more familiar to a less experienced practitioner, its core principles apply universally. We all face complex situations.
“This example was created using AI tools to maintain confidentiality and protect sensitive information.”
The Scenario: A Hospital Social Worker’s Ethical Tightrope
Sam, a social worker at the hospital, came to our supervision session clearly burdened. He’d been working with an older client. This client, despite having full mental capacity, was consistently refusing vital medical treatment. Sam felt caught. Ethically conflicted. He wasn’t sure how to balance the client’s right to choose with his own professional duty to protect their well-being. This complex ethical dilemma became the ‘event’ he brought to our discussion. I could see the weight of it on him.
The Exploration Phase: Unpacking Layers of Values
During our exploration, I asked Sam to detail the specific interactions. “What exactly was said? How did the client communicate their refusal? What non-verbal cues did you notice?”
Sam recounted several frustrating conversations. “They just kept repeating, ‘I know what’s best for me.’ But I could see their health worsening. I felt this immense pressure. Like I was failing to advocate. Yet, I also knew I couldn’t force them. It was a real tug-of-war inside me,” he explained, his voice strained.
We delved into his feelings: the frustration, the helplessness, the deep ethical anguish. “What assumptions were you making about the client’s decision?” I gently probed. “What underlying fears or values might be driving this refusal?” This led Sam to consider the client’s cultural background. Their past experiences. Aspects he hadn’t fully explored before. “I realised I was so focused on the medical outcome,” Sam reflected, “that I hadn’t truly listened to their deep-seated narrative about dignity and control. This was a massive insight for him.”
The Experimentation Phase: Crafting Empathetic Interventions
With this newfound understanding, we moved to experimentation. “Given this insight, what are some different ways you could approach your next conversation?” I asked. We brainstormed several options. Instead of just focusing on the medical benefits, Sam decided to try validating the client’s feelings about autonomy. “Perhaps I could start by saying, ‘I understand this is a very difficult decision, and your feelings about control are valid. Can you tell me more about what ‘control’ means to you in this situation?'” he suggested, a new light in his eyes.
We also discussed involving their whānau, if appropriate. Exploring alternatives to treatment. Ones that might align better with the client’s values, while still prioritising their health. Sam committed to trying this more person-centred, culturally sensitive approach. He would use it in his next interaction.
The Evaluation Phase: Learning and Adapting
In our next supervision session, Sam reported back. “It was still tough, but it felt profoundly different,” he shared, a hint of relief in his voice. “When I acknowledged their need for control, they seemed to soften. They still refused treatment, yes, but they opened up about a past traumatic experience. One where they felt completely powerless. I learned so much more about their life story. Far more than I ever had before. While the immediate outcome — treatment acceptance — wasn’t achieved, our therapeutic relationship deepened dramatically.”
We evaluated the outcome: Sam hadn’t ‘solved’ the problem in the way he initially hoped. But he had gained a richer, far more nuanced understanding of the client. He also learned invaluable lessons. Lessons about balancing advocacy with profound respect for autonomy. And the power of truly empathetic listening. “I learned that sometimes ‘success’ isn’t about getting the outcome you want,” Sam reflected, “but about genuinely understanding and respecting the client’s journey. Even if it goes against your own professional perspective.” This new understanding became a new ‘concrete experience.’ It allowed us to continue exploring ethical decision-making. The cycle continued, each turn deepening Sam’s practice and ethical acumen. It’s a truly humbling and powerful process.
The Enduring Value of the Reflective Learning Model
This model is far more than just a technique; it’s a fundamental philosophy for continuous professional development. It actively pushes us to look beyond surface-level issues. To delve into the intricate nuances of our practice. Our personal reactions. Our professional impact. This is how we move beyond simply ‘doing the work’ to truly understanding, mastering, and transforming our effectiveness. For me, it’s not just about guiding you. It’s about empowering you. Empowering you to become a more adaptable, insightful, and resilient practitioner. Especially here in the ever-evolving landscape of social work in Aotearoa New Zealand. It helps us integrate our lived experiences, our core values, and our growing knowledge into a truly coherent and effective practice.
Remember, the ultimate goal isn’t to find a single ‘right’ answer. Those are often elusive in our complex field. Instead, it’s about cultivating a deeper capacity. The capacity to explore multiple perspectives. To navigate ambiguity with greater ease. To approach uncertainty with increased confidence. This is particularly vital in social work. Here, definitive solutions are rare. A deep, contextual understanding is paramount for ethical and effective practice.
I hope this detailed exploration has offered a clearer, more practical understanding. A true glimpse into how the Reflective Learning Model functions within professional supervision. It’s a powerful tool, one that I have personally witnessed transform the professional journeys of many dedicated practitioners. A privilege to be a part of.
Davys, A., & Beddoe, L. (2020). Best Practice in Professional Supervision, Second Edition: A Guide for the Helping Professions. Jessica Kingsley
About The Author
